" It will work, if you forget all the reasons that it won't"
Showing posts with label The Dream That Wasn't. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Dream That Wasn't. Show all posts

Sunday, October 19, 2014

The Dream That Wasn't

Chapter: Eklavya



I was packing my bags to go back to Delhi forever when my landlord came rushing inside my room without even caring to knock on the door.

“I read about your Dream on mool-dhara” my landlord said and fell silent. His eyes were stuck on the brown leather suitcase lying on the top of the almirah in my room.

“So… did you like the article?” I asked him in an attempt to distract him.

He looked at me and said, “I want to narrate you a story”.

* * * * * * *

I remember I was coming back home one day when I saw a huge crowd gathered outside my house. There was a make-shift stage in our veranda and a leader was giving a speech from it. My father was standing right beside this man.

“Who is he?’ I asked my amma.

“He is the new president of Indian National Congress, Subhash Chandra Bose” she replied.

At first I thought Netaji was too young to be a Congress President. There were other stalwarts in Congress like Nehru; then why should Congress elect a young leader like him as their president?

“Oh, his status is even bigger than Pandit Nehru”, my Amma replied.

I sat among the crowd to listen to Netaji. He was a powerful speaker. His ideas were unconventional unlike his contemporaries. For example when other Congress leaders like Gandhiji and Nehru wanted freedom from British in phases, Netaji was advocating complete, unconditional Independence for India. He was demanding ‘Poorna Swaraj’. I decided to join Netaji there and then.

Netaji's demand for Poorna Swaraj and idea to use force against the British to achieve means had won him fans in Congress. But Gandhiji was unhappy with this cultural change in Congress. Netaji’s schemes were against the moral principles of Gandhiji. In Gandhiji’s opinion Nehru was a more appropriate leader to lead Congress.

To put it aptly, the triangular relationship of Gandhiji, Nehru and Netaji  could be compared with Guru Dronacharya, Arjuna and Eklavya from Mahabharat. It was a known fact that Netaji considered Gandhiji as his mentor. Rather Netaji was the first person to address Gandhiji as 'Father of our Nation' long before the title was officially given to Gandhiji after independence. But Gandhiji seldom gave Netaji that status of a pupil. Gandhiji had a special liking and an even more special plan for Nehru.

But within Congress, in presence of Netaji, Nehru’s importance was diminishing. And Gandhiji-led clique didn’t like it at all. So in the next year’s President Elections of Congress, Gandhji decided to place a candidate against Netaji. Gandhji was confident that his candidate would be more acceptable to people than Netaji himself.

But my father, who was also Netaji’s closest ally, understood the game plan well in advance. He galvanised all the south Indian votes of Congress towards Netaji. I, myself travelled to different places to convey this message of my father to other Congress leaders who wanted to see Netaji getting re-elected.

When the election took place Netajii was re-elected as the President of the Indian National Congress and Gandhiji’s candidate suffered a defeat. For Gandhiji, the water had breached the gates of the dam.

In a Congress rally, with Nehru sitting on one side and Netaji on the other side, Gandhiji whispered into Netaji’s ears.

“For a guru to have a pupil, the pupil must be ready to offer his guru a guru-dakshina".

"Bapu, please ask me. All I have, is yours" replied Netaji with complete sincerity.

"Leave Congress for Nehru."

Netaji stood up on the dais and announced his resignation there and then.




* * * * * * *

"Thus the Eklavya whom you were seeking in your article on mool-dhara was none other than Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose who gave away his proverbial thumb as a guru dakshina. That was his dedication towards Gandhiji" my landlord concluded. His eyes had become wet.

“I know what happened next” I interrupted my landlord.

“He went to Russia and Germany to seek help, but their response was disappointing. From there he went to Japan, where Subhash Chandra Bose established the foundation of Indian National Army. But the Japanese forces were defeated by the British forces in the Battle of Kohima and Imphal. And as a result, INA was forced to pull back.”

I didn't stop there.

“All the soldiers of INA were imprisoned by the British Army. To avoid arrest, Subhash Chandra Bose escaped to Japan. And then a Japanese plane carrying him crashed in Taiwan and he died.”

“Not all of that is true” interrupted my landlord.

“Which part are you talking about?” I grew curious.

* * * * * * *

Netaji didn't leave India before forming his own political party, Forward Block. My father was appointed secretary of the party. Netaji understood the risk India could suffer under the propaganda politics of Nehru and to some extent that of Jinnah who wanted a separate country for Muslims living in India.

Needless to say Gandhiji was happy because now Nehru could easily establish his dominion over Congress. But what did Gandhiji get in return from Nehru?

The independence was around the corner and Nehru was the president of Congress again. Gandhiji had complete faith in his favourite pupil that Nehru would never let the country be divided. Gandhiji assured everyone that if at all the country divides, it will only be divided over his dead body.

Nehru was in a hurry to be the Prime Minister. He no longer wanted to wait for the truce between Hindus and Muslims in India. He let the partition took place.

* * * * * * *

“Jawaharlal Nehru went on become the first prime minister of the divided India and Gandhiji died 5 months later in January 1948” I recollected.

“Yes. My father was present at his crematorium along with Netaji….”

“With Netaji? You mean to say Subhash Chandra Bose was alive when Gandhiji died! But his plane crashed in 1945..”

“He never died in any plane crash. He was always alive.” revealed my landlord.

* * * * * * *

India was partitioned in 1947. At that time he was in Lahore, in disguise, helping people to migrate safely to India. My father and many other associates of Netaji helped him in this task. When Kashmir was burning after independence he took up the work of providing relief and rehabilitation to the people. He used his experience of setting up Indian National Army to tackle this gigantic task with efficiency and resourcefulness.

Congress, under the leadership of Nehru, created a complete mess in Kashmir. He thought of making a political comeback in the general elections of 1951 and set things right in India. But Congress swept the elections and Nehru was elected the Prime Minister of India again. Forward Block couldn't win many seats.

And then somewhere in 1950s Nehru setup a commission to find out what actually happened to Subhash Chandra Bose. My father told me that Nehru had come to know that Netaji was alive and hence he had grown suspicious of Netaji coming back into mainstream politics. As a result, anyone who was found involved with Netaji and the Indian National Army was put behind the bars. Police came to our house also and arrested my father on the charges of treason. My father died in jail 4 years later.

But Netaji was untraceable.

Netaji perhaps realised that it was better to die as a hero than to live long enough to see you become a villain. And in my opinion, it was the right thing to do. We all love heroes who die tragic deaths, don’t we? And if there is a mystery involved around him, that is even better.
  
Soon Forward Block became redundant in most part of the country in the absence of Netaji. Dynasty became the policy and politics of Indian National Congress. There was nothing left of Netaji other than a troubled legacy.

What you wrote in your last article could actually have been true if Netaji had his way.

Shahid Afridi and Wasim Akram would have been playing for India. Mahindra & Mahindra would have been Mahindra & Mohammad. Kashmir would have continued to be known as 'The Heaven on Earth'. Terrorism wouldn't have existed. And India would have extended from Afghanistan-Iran in the west to Myanmar in the east, from Kashmir in the north to Kanyakumari in South.

* * * * * * *

“So what happened to Netaji if he didn’t die in the plane crash?” the mystery was still unsolved in my head.

“Honestly speaking, I don’t know. He lived a life of ‘bahrupiya’ for many years and never stayed at one place for long.”

“When was the last time you saw Subhash Chandra Bose?”

“In August of 1975. He had come to stay with us. He stayed in this house, in the room where you stay… And then one day he went to the beach for a walk and never returned. He left his brown leather suitcase behind.”

* * * * * * *

I pulled down the brown leather suitcase from the top of the almirah. 

It had a combination lock with three wheels of alphabets. I rotated the first wheel till “S”, second wheel till “C” and third till “B”. The lock opened.

The suitcase had clothes of plain white cotton. There was a case for spectacles. There was also a diary and an un-posted letter to someone called ‘Emilie’.

I opened the letter; it had a photograph inside. In the photograph Gandhiji was sitting in the centre whispering something in Subhas Chandra Bose’s ears, who was sitting on his left. Jawaharlal Nehru was sitting on the right side of Gandhiji.

There was a message written with blue pen on the other side of the picture.

“Probably this was the moment that changed the course of Indian history forever… Pakistan would never have been created”

* * * * * * *

Friday, April 4, 2014

The Dream That Wasn't


It was morning.

I opened my eyes slowly. At first, there was too much of light for my iris to take in. But it adjusted itself soon enough.

There was a unique calmness in the room, or perhaps it was just a state of my state of mind; it was a kind of calmness you experience after having been dreaming deep in your sleep. And when you wake up, it takes a while before your mind can differentiate between what is real and what is not.

The only sound that my ears could gather was the awful din created by the rotating fan hanging from the ceiling of my room. The old brown leather suitcase was lying on the top of the almirah right in front of me. My house-owner had told me once the suitcase belonged to his father’s friend who had lived in my room 50 years ago. When I occupied this room in their house, he had taken this suitcase out from under my bed and kept it on the top of the almirah to make more space for my own luggage.

I raised my neck a little bit to look at the textured fostered glass of my room’s window right above my head. It was white and bright, an indication that the clouds of the previous night had given way to the sun this morning.

It was raining heavily in Chennai last night while I was leaving the office, an unusual setting for this time of the year. Hoping that the rain would drowse down in a while, I continued to stay in office even after the regular working hours. But the rain gods didn't oblige for a long time.

Next I remember that it was already midnight when I finally left my office. As a result there was no auto or bus or any other kind of public transport available on the road, walking back home was the only option for me.

My office and home are separated by 3 kilometres; as a result I was drenched completely by the time I reached home. My bed was still moist in the morning, I could feel it. My wet clothes were lying on a chair near my bed, still dripping some drops of water in the pool created right below the chair.

It was Saturday and a holiday for me, I wanted to sleep for some more time. I looked for my pillow. It was lying near my feet. I pulled it closer and squeezed it tight between my arms. A tag stitched to the pillow, popped out of the pillow cover. I noticed the words “Recron” written on it in big black letters and “Lahore, India” in the next line.

I had never noticed that tag before. I closed my eyes for a moment and opened it again to check if I read that right first time. It was still there in the second line - “Lahore, India”.

I wondered why anyone would write India when Lahore is in Pakistan. Or was it a misprint in the hands of pillow makers? I was having a heavy head and so I chose to ignore the mistake and close my eyes to sleep for some more time.

I woke up again sometime later. The tag was still there with the mention of Lahore and India side-by-side in the second line. It must be a major printing error, I took it for granted. I grabbed my wrist watch lying on the bed. Even that had rainwater inside but the needles were still ticking. The time was quarter past 9.

I got out of the bed, went straight to the toilet to carry out with my daily morning customary. After freshening up, I took my wallet from inside the poly-bag and keys of the house. I locked the house and started walking towards the idli-vada shop where I have my daily breakfast.

As I approached the shop, I saw its owner fighting with an unknown man who had apparently parked his big black Scorpio right in front of his shop. I noticed Mahindra’s brand symbol on the bonnet was a bit different on that car. It wasn't the usual two-way-road-narrowing-down-to-infinity. Rather it had something that seemed to me like triple M put one over the other. I doubted if it was really Mahindra’s Scorpio.

I took a walk around the car and reached the rear end of the SUV. The car was indeed a Scorpio, but the makers of the car were meant to be ‘Mahindra & Mohammed’. It was strange because for I had always known the company as 'Mahindra & Mahindra’.

The owner of the car must be some nut, I thought, trying to give a fancy touch to his car. I clicked a picture of the same and uploaded on Facebook. Then went inside the shop and ordered for a masala dosa. While my masala dosa was getting ready, I went to buy a copy of The Times of India from the next shop.
The front page of the paper read:

“AFRIDI’S SIX HELPS INDIA REACH FINALS OF T20 WORLD CUP”

Now this was the third weirdness of the day and the day had just started! What was bloody wrong with this day? How could TOI do such a blunder mistake on its front page headline? How could they write that Shahid Afridi, a cricketer actually from Pakistan, supposedly batting for India, scored 9 runs of the last 4 balls to help India reach finals of T20 World Cup!

I snatched a copy of The Hindu from the stands. Even Hindu had a similar article about “The Comeback Man Shahid Afridi”. It also had a photo of Shahid Afridi wearing the blue Indian jersey. I picked up Indian Express and Deccan Herald as well. They were no different.

Indian Express alongside also reported that India was planning to invest Rs 1000 Crores to build a new port at Gwadar, in Baluchistan, 100 kilometers from the border India shares with Iran. Deccan Herald carried pictures of the new Islamabad Airport inaugurated by Airport Authority of India. It said this was supposedly the 5th major airport-after Hyderabad, Bangalore, Delhi and Mumbai-to be built on PPP model.

I was chewing the last bite of my dosa still confused by the strangeness of the day when my phone rang. It was Prateeksha. I was thrilled that she called me up. I so desperately wanted to share with her the weirdness in my life today. I quickly swallowed my last bite, even before breaking them down into tiny bits inside my mouth.

“Did you see today’s newspaper?” I spoke up in excitement ignoring hello(s) and hi(s).

“Is the news of Sana Khan and her car crash already in the newspaper?”

“Who is Sana Khan now, Prateeksha? I am talking about Shahid Afridi playing for India in yesterday’s match... it is in every paper today”

“So? What’s the big deal about it?” she sounded indifferent.

“It is a big deal. He doesn't play for India, he plays for Pakistan yaar”

“What? What’s Pakistan?”

I ignored her reaction because I know she rarely follows cricket. The only cricketer she knew about was Virat Kohli and MS Dhoni because I had written about them in my articles on mool-dhara. And of course she knew of Dravid, Ganguly and Tendulkar as well. I told her I would speak to her later.

I went back home. Opened my laptop and connected to the internet. Yahoo, my homepage, was displaying the news about the death of the same female whom Prateeksha had mentioned to me sometime back. Yahoo reported that Sana and Babar Khan, apparently India’s most popular Bollywood couple, were on their way from Mumbai to Lonavala in a car when the vehicle, driven by Babar, went out of control and crashed. I had never heard of neither Sana nor Babar Khan before.

But they seem to be someone really admired in Bollywood. NDTV website had uploaded some photographs of other Khans and Kapoors from Bollywood, everyone dressed in white, visiting her home in Mumbai to pay condolence. Tweets from Anupam Kher, Shashi Tharoor, Gul Panaag among many others also kept flashing on the upper right corner of the page.

I googled Shahid Afridi. It threw up several links. I opened the Wikipedia link. It said Shahid Afridi was an All-Rounder from India. I searched for Wasim Akram next; even he played for Indian cricket as per cricinfo. I checked for Imraan Khan. Google offered images of him standing next to Aravind Kejriwal wearing the traditional “main hoon aam aadmi” topi. Shoib Akhtar was too an Indian.

These men were actually from Pakistan, but none of the website showed them as Pakistanis. Every page on internet claimed they were Indians. I searched for Pakistan next. Google returned no result.

This was unbelievable. I searched for India on Google. It threw up a million search option. I navigated the cursor to maps-the first link in the list. The maps page showed that the boundaries of India extended from Afghanistan-Iran in the west to Myanmar in the east, from Kashmir in the north to Kanyakumari in South. I was shocked.

Where did Pakistan disappear? Was I spelling it right? Or was I missing some alphabet?

I tried various spellings of Pakistan; nothing but only one yielded result.

As per a document with the National Archives of India, in 1933, an activist Choudhry Rahmat Ali published a pamphlet titled “Now or Never” demanding a separate Muslim state, distinct from India as a solution to the Hindu-Muslim problem that had surfaced during that time. There he first coined the term “PAKSTAN”.

“I am enclosing herewith an appeal, on behalf of thirty million Muslim brethren who live in PAKSTAN, for the demand of the recognition of their national status, as distinct from the other inhabitants of India”

He was referring to the names of the five northern states of British India: Punjab, Afghania Province (North-West Frontier Province), Kashmir, Sindh and Baluchistan that had the maximum concentration of Muslims outside the Bengal region.

On a little more digging I discovered an article that claimed two of the tallest leaders from Indian National Congress-Nehru and Jinnah-who were too ambitious to get the top job after British left India-supported Ali’s idea. The article claimed that if the country was divided they would not have to compete against each other in the race for pradhaan mantri ki gaddi; a race that was already becoming ugly every passing day as the British had started giving hints of leaving.

But there was one rising-star within the Congress, a defiant patriot, who ensured that personal ambitions of the two stalwarts-one supposedly a favourite of Gandhiji and other the head of All-India Muslim League-would not let the foundation of the nation crumble where millions lived, at least till the time he was alive. Hence he took it upon himself to make sure the country is freed as a united India.

But perhaps it was the influential Gandhiji who made the most crucial decision when he chose wisdom over nepotism. Unlike Dronacharya of Mahabharat, Gandhiji chose Eklavya over Arjun. Thus country was spared of a division and PAKSTAN was never created.

And it was true because there was nothing on Google regarding the 1947, 1965, 1971 or even 1999 Kargil war. Kashmir was never terrorised. India wasn't spending Rs 2 Lakh Crores on the military expenses to protect its borders. Even the relations with China were cordial since China recognised the influence India had in South and South-East Asia region because of its historically enriched trade-cultural-political relations with its neighbouring countries. And its influence over Muslim dominated middle-east nations considering India housed the biggest population of Muslims in the world-Shia and Sunni.

There was no history of Indo-Pakistan cricket ties. Rather we had the best cricket team in the world. We were No. 1 in hockey too, winning the last 3 of the 5 World Cups. Legends like Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan and Nazia Hassan belonged to India. Jal, Strings and Adnan Sami, were all Indians.

King Edward Medical College of Lahore and AIIMS in New Delhi were pioneers in medical research. Cotton Industry of Punjab was the biggest cotton market of the world, giving us a lead in the world market that was nearly double to the second biggest market. Port in Chittagong, Vishakhapatnam, Chennai, Kochi, Mumbai and Karachi gave India a strategic advantage over the Indian Ocean in South Asia. Nothing could bypass us.

Manufacturing and investments bloomed and so did tourism. India offered everything from archaeological sites of Mohenjo Daro in Sindh dating back to 2600 BCE to present day financial and industrial centres of Gurgaon in Haryana.

I paused and wondered what happened to Bangladesh then. Was it ever created? Google had no answers for Bangladesh, even after trying all possible combinations with the alphabets that made up Bangladesh.

I could not believe this alternation of history at first. But slowly it all made sense to me. Everything was so neat and real. I was beginning to get convinced that there was no Pakistan; that there was no division that took place, ever.

But then, I had read about Pakistan in my school books. I had heard my grandmother narrated the horrific stories of partition. I had spoken about Pakistan during cricket world cup matches with my friends. I had seen films made on Kargil war with my family. What did they mean? Or even if Pakistan never existed from where this idea of Pakistan creep into my mind? Was I hallucinating? Or was I dreaming all these years? Or was I dreaming now?

My phone rang again. There was a message from Prateeksha.

“Btw when are you planning to come back to Lahore? We are waiting”


*     *     *      *     *     *     *

It was morning.

I opened my eyes slowly. At first, there was too much of light for my iris to take in. But it adjusted itself soon enough.

There was a unique calmness in the room, or perhaps it was just a state of my state of mind; it was a kind of calmness you experience after having been dreaming deep in your sleep. And when you wake up, it takes a while before your mind can differentiate between what is real and what is not.

The only sound that my ears could gather was the awful din created by the rotating fan hanging from the ceiling of my room. The old brown leather suitcase was lying on the top of the almirah right in front of me. My house-owner had told me once the suitcase belonged to his father’s friend who had lived in my room 50 years ago. When I occupied this room in their house, he had taken this suitcase out from under my bed and kept it on the top of the almirah to make more space for my own luggage.

I raised my neck a little bit to look at the textured fostered glass of my room’s window right above my head. It was white and bright, an indication that the clouds of the previous night had given way to the sun this morning.

I tried to recollect what happened yesterday.

I wanted to reach home early last night (it was a Friday) and wanted to write a new article for mool-dhara. I had thought of something - "What if India was never divided at the time of Independence?"

It was raining heavily in Chennai last night while I was leaving the office, an unusual setting for this time of the year. Hoping that the rain would drowse down in a while, I continued to stay in office even after the regular working hours. I planned to utilise my time by doing research for my article. I came to know many things that I never known before. Like the history of Mahindra & Mahindra, which was initially steel trading company started by K.C. Mahindra and J.C. Mahindra in partnership with their friend Malik Ghulam Mohammed who later moved to Pakistan during partition.

There were a lot of articles on the cotton industry in erstwhile Punjab and how it flourished in its heyday courtesy to the Grand Trunk Road that offered the traders a free passage from Chittagong, now in Bangladesh to Kabul now in Afghanistan via Kolkata, Varanasi, Delhi in India and Lahore and Peshawar in Pakistan. I had even read articles on the leadership tussle between Nehru and Jinnah too.

I remembered I was so engrossed and astounded by my historical discoveries that I didn’t realise that it was already midnight.  My curiosity had multiplied with every new article. The layers of history were uncovering before me and I wanted to dig deeper and deeper. I would have stayed more if it was not for the watchman who wanted to lock the office.

The rain hadn't stopped yet and I knew I won’t get any public transport as well. I will have to walk three kilometres distance from my office to home on foot. I found a poly-bag lying on the table of my colleague’s desk. I safely wrapped my phone inside it and started walking back home. I reached home completely drenched. I remember I reached at 1 AM.

As I washed my face after cleaning my teeth, the scenes from the dream of last night flashed before me. What a dream it was!! It had put all the pieces of information that I collected during my research at the right places and given me an apt story to write. I had the perfect plot and all the information to begin writing my next article for mool-dhara. I had all the information but one.

Who was that defiant patriot, the Eklavya, whom Gandhiji chose in my dream over his favourite Nehru?

None of the articles on net could confirm me about his real identity. Perhaps I would have to reopen history books to find that out. I wasn't in a hurry because the second part can wait. For now I had the first part and I decided to give it the title “The dream that wasn't”. 

I started writing.

*     *     *      *     *     *     *